علم الکلام کی تشکیل نو: فکرِمابعد جدیدیت کے تناظر میں

A Rationale for Reconstructing Ilm ul-Kalam in the Perspective of Postmodern Frameworks

  • Azhar Hussain Ph. D scholar Department of Islamic Thought and Civilization, University of Management and Technology, Lahore.
  • Prof. Dr. Tahira Basharat Professor, Department of Islamic Thought and Civilization, University of Management and Technology, Lahore.
  • Prof. Dr. Muhammad Tahir Mustafa Professor, Department of Islamic Thought and Civilization, University of Management and Technology, Lahore.
Keywords: Derrida,, Ghazali, Iqbal,, Lyotard,, Modernism,, Muslim Ilamul-Kalam,, Post-modernism,, Religion.

Abstract

In the Muslim tradition, Kalam is a science which justifies religions doctrines and commands on rational grounds. In the Abbasid Caliphate period, the science of Kalam was in its climax. Muslim Mutkalmeen used to reject the profane doctrines of the western modernism, intellectually and logically, in their own respective epochs. However, in the 1980s, postmodernism was emerged, in reaction to modernism, which promoted more profane doctrines. Postmodernism has not only rejected the doctrines of modernism but also the idea of Absolute Reality. Postmodernism develops a new path by repudiating the foundations of modernism and its religious criticism. Hence, in this article, we provide a rationale for the reconstruction of Kalam in perspective of the postmodern frameworks so the current and future students of religion could discover new developments in knowledge and research. By understanding the significance of Kalam, they could not only enhance their intellectual capabilities, but also contribute for the development of Kalam, which had become dormant under the attacks of modernism and then postmodernism.

References

البیاضی ، الحنفی، کمال الدین احمد ،اشارات المراہمن عبارات الامام (القاہرہ: مصطفیٰ الباہی الحلبی، 1939 )، 28-29

Al-byāḍī, Al-ḥnfī, Kmāl-al-dīn āḥmd, ishārāt-al-mrāhn Ebārāt-al-imām (Al-Kāhirh: Muṣṭfa-al-bāhī-al-Ḥlbī, 1939), 28-29

الفارابی ، ابو نصر، احصاء العلوم (القاہرہ: لانحلو المصریہ ،1968 )، 70-69

Al-Fārābī, abw nṣr, Eṣā-al-ulwm, (Al-Kāhirh: lā nḥl w al-miṣriya, 1968), 69-70

الغزالی، ابی حامد، محمد، الاقتصاد فی الاعتقاد، شارح: الدکتورۃ انصاف رمضان (بیروت: کتیبہ 2003ء)، 21

Al-Ghāzāli, abi-ḥāmid, Muḥamad, al-Iqtaṣād fil etiqād, shāriḥ: al-duktūr insāf ramḍān (byrūt: kutybh, 2003), 21

ابن خلدون، بن محمد، عبد الرحمٰن ، مقدمہ ابن خلدون، الجز الثالث ( قاہرہ: لجنۃ البیان العربی ، 1385ھ (، 1169

Ibn-i-khuldūn, bn Muḥamad, abdu-al-riḥmān, mukadimh ibn i khuldūn, al-djuz al-thālth (Kāhirh: li djnh-tu-al-bayān al-arbi, 1385Hijra), 1169

Van Ess, J. The Logical Structure of Islamic Theology, GE, grunebaum (ed.) Logic in classical Islamic Culture (Germany: Giorgio Levi Della Vida Biennial Conference, Otto Harrassowitz, 1970), 21

جلالپوری، علی عباس، اقبال کا علم الکلام ( لاہور: تخلیقات، 1972)، 19

djlāl puri, ali abās, Iqbāl kā Ilm al kalām (Lahore: takhliqaat, 1972), 19

شبلی نعمانی ، علامہ، علم الکلام (کراچی: نفیس اکیڈمی، 1979)، 26

Shibli numāni, alāma, ilm al kalām (karchi: nafees academy, 1979), 26

امین، احمد، ظہر الاسلام، طبع ثانیہ، ج2 (قاہرہ :مؤسسۃ ہنداوی للتعلیم والثقافۃ،1961)، 3

Amin, Ahmed, ẓur al Islām, ṭaba thanih, dj 2 (Kāhirh: Moassisa hindawi, liltaleem wa alsaqafa, 1961), 3

نعمانی، شبلی، علم الکلام، 35

Numāni, shbli, Ilm al kalām, 35

ابن الندیم، الفہرست، مترجم: مولانا اسحاق بھٹی (لاہور: ادارہ ثقافت اسلامیہ)، 136

Ibn al nadim, al-fhrist, mutarjim: mulānā Isḥāk Bhati (Lāhur: Idara thakafat i Islāmiah), 136

افضل الدین، شاہ ولی اللہ کے علم الکلام کا تنقیدی مطالعہ، تحقیقی مقالہ برائے ایم فل ( اسلام آباد : شعبہ علوم اسلامیہ علامہ اقبال اوپن یونیورسٹی ، 1996)، 31

Afḍal al din, shāḥ wali u allah kay Ilm al kalām kā tanqidi muṭaliah, tḥkiki makālah brāay M.Phil (Islamabad: shuba ulum Islāmiah, Alāmah Ikbāl open university, 1996), 31

خان، سید احمد، سر، تفیسر القرآن وھو الہدیٰ و الفرقان (لاہور: رفاہ عام ٹیم پریس) 2

Khān, sayd, Aḥmd, sar, Tafsīr al kurān w huwā al hudā wa al-furqān (Lāhor: rafāh i am Ṭeam pres) 2

نعمانی، شبلی، علم الکلام ،28

Numāni, Shbli, Ilm al kalām, 28

Muhammad Iqbal, Allama, The reconstruction of religious thoughts in Islam ( Lahore: Iqbal Academy Pakistan, 1989)

Jencks, Charles, What is Postmodernism? (London, UK: Academy Editions, 1996), 20

آفاقی،اقبال ،ڈاکٹر، مابعد جدیدیت فلسفہ و تاریخ کے تناظر میں ( فیصل آباد : مثال پبلشرز ،رحیم سینٹر،2013)، 163

Āfāki, Iqbal, Doctor, Mā-bad-jadīdiat (falsfa wa tārīkh k tanāzur mein (Faiṣalābād: mithāl publishar, Rahīm center, 2013), 163

Rudolf Pannwitz, Die Krisis der Europaeischen Kultur (Nuenberg: Hans Carl, 1917), 64,Cited in Modernity, Postmodernity and Islamic tradition, Humaira Ahmad, PhD thesis, Lahore, University of the Punjab,2004, 73

www.Wikipedia.org/wiki/postmodernism

ندیم، احمد، پروفیسر، ڈاکٹر، مابعد جدیدیت اور اسلامی تعلیمات (لاہور : کتاب محل ، 2016ء)، 120

Nadīm Ahmad, Professor, Doctor, Mā-bad-Jadīyat awr Islāmī talīmāt (Lahore: kitāb maḥal, 2016), 120

مابعد جدیدیت فلسفہ و تاریخ کے تناظر میں، 190

Mā-bad-jadīdiat (falsfa wa tārīkh k tanāzur mein, 190

Ihab Hassan, The Postmodern Turn: Essays in Postmodern Theory and Culture (Ohio Columbus, 1987), 25

Modernity, Postmodernity and Islamic tradition, 73

مابعد جدیدیت فلسفہ و تاریخ کے تناظر میں، 175

Mā-bad-jadīdiat (falsfa wa tārīkh k tanāzur mein, 175

Barthes, Roland, The death of the author (London: Image Music text, Fantana, 1977), 145

Plant, Raymond, The Politics of Post Modernity, Edited by Good, M.M, James and Velody, Irving (England: Cambridge University Press, 1998), 83

Smith, Anna Marie, Laclau and Mouffe (London: Routledge, 11 New Fetter Lane, 1998), 9

Kellner, Douglas. & Best, Steven, Postmodern politics and the battle for the future, A journal of New political Science, Routledge, Volume 20, Number 3 (1998) 283-299 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/07393149808429830

Ludwig, Wittgenstein, Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus, Translator: Ogden, C.K. (Edinburgh: Edinburgh Press, 1922) 39

مابعد جدیدیت فلسفہ و تاریخ کے تناظر میں، 178

Mā-bad-jadīdiat (falsfa wa tārīkh k tanāzur mein, 178

Derrida, Jacques, Margins of philosophy, Translation by Alan Bass (Chicago: The Harvester Press, 1982) 310

نارنگ، گوپی چند، ساختیات اور مشرقی شعریات (لاہور: سنگ میل پبلی کیشنز، 1994) 205

Nārang, gopī chand, sākhtiāt awr mashriki sheriyāt (Lahore: sang-e-meel publications, 1994), 205

Barthes, Roland, Criticism and Truth, Translated by Katrine Pilcher Keuneman (London: The Athlone Press 1987), 35

آفاقی، اقبال، ڈاکٹر، اثبات (فیصل آباد: ممبئی و نقاط، 2012)، 57

Āfāki, Iqbal, Doctor, Athbāt (Faysal Ābād: Mumbai wa naqāt, 2012), 57

Focault, Michel, What is Author? In textual strategies, 1969, 299-314 https://www.open.edu/openlearn/ocw/pluginfile.php/624849/mod_resource/content/1/a840_1_michel_foucault.pdf

Focault, Michel, The Archeology of Knowledge (New York: Pantheon Books 1972) P27

Lyotard, Jean-Francois, Jean, The Postmodern Condition: A Report on knowledge, Translation from the French by Geoff Bennington & Brian massumi (Manchester: Theory and History Literature volume 10), P xxiii

Lyotard, Postmodern Condition P36

Jameson, Fredric, Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism (Durham, USA: Duke University press,1997)35

Baudrillard, Jean, Simulacra and simulations, Translated by: Glaser, Sheila-Faria (USA: The University of Michigan Press, 1994), 81

CF. Foucault, The Order of Discourse, Untying the text Edited by: Young, Robort (Boston, London: Oxford, Routledge & kegan paul, 1981), 129

ٰAppignanesi, Richard & Garratt, Chris, Introducing Postmodernism (Cambridge, UK: Icon Books Ltd, 2004), 83

Fukuyama, Francis, The End of History and the Last Man (New York: The free press, A division of macmillan, Inc, 1992), 339

Lyotard, Jean-Francois, & Thebaud, Jean-Loup, Just Gaming, Translated By: Godzich, Wladyslaw-Bougusz (Manchester: University Press, 1985), 9

Danial Bell, The Coming of Postindustrial Society, A Venture in Social Forecasting (New York: Basic Books, 1973), 477

Jacques Ellul, Betrayal of the West, Translated by: Connell, Mathew J.O (New York, USA: University of Minnesota press, 1978), 195

Cf. Fredric, Jameson, Postmodernism or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism (United States: Duke university press, 1991), 423

Lyotard, The Postmodern Condition: 21

محمد ذوالقرنین، ڈاکٹر، عصر حاضر میں علم الکلا م کے مناہج اور ان کی تشکیل جدید (اسلام آباد: سہ ماہی مجلہ ، تعلیم و تحقیق، جلد 2، شمارہ 1،جنوری تا مارچ 2020)

Muhammad Zulqarnain, Doctor, Asr-e-Hāzir mein Ilm al kalām ky manāhij awr aunkī tashkīl e jadīd (Islāmābād: sehmāhi mujallah, taleem o tehqeeq, jild 2, shumārah 1, January to march2020)

Published
2022-12-31
How to Cite
Hussain, A., Prof. Dr. Tahira Basharat, & Prof. Dr. Muhammad Tahir Mustafa. (2022). علم الکلام کی تشکیل نو: فکرِمابعد جدیدیت کے تناظر میں. Al Qalam, 27(2), 246-265. https://doi.org/10.51506/al qalam.v27i2.1728