Effective enforcement of Sharia and Pakistani law through embedding DNA in the evidence Act An Analytical Review

  • Mufti Dilawar Khan, Dr Hafiz Muhammad Haussain Lecturer: Department of Islamic studies University of Lahore,Sargodha Campus
Keywords: Islamic law, DNA, comparative,assessment, Fingerprints, blood reports, testimony

Abstract

These are the two lights which guide human existence on each and every aspect of life. The coming together of humanity is the basis of formation of society, which naturally cultivates conflicts and issues. These issues are related to health, wealth, honor and dignity. The Islamic law promulgates “Testimony” as the rule for mitigating these issues. Using these claims of plaintiff are judged in court of law. Issues are a plenty, but the most important ones are the ones which are related to human life like, murder, rape, defamation and theft. This is also known as “Hudood-ul-Allah” Advancement of Human Civilization has given rise to new issues, one of which is “Testimony”.  Can these new forms of evidence (forensic reports, DNA, fingerprints, blood reports, audio, and video) be equivalent to testimony presented by a Human being? Especially in Hudood cases where most often the loss of human life is observed. The distribution of topics in the article is as follows. In the first and second part’ portion of this article issues related to testimony, meaning of testimony, important sources of testimony and rules & regulation of testimony are discussed. The last portion sheds light on latest forms of types Evidence used in Testimonies and their legal status in Sharia Law.

 

References

۔ Al-Baqara:282:2

۔ Al-Haskafi, Muhammad Alauddin, Al-Dar al-Mukhtar, (Dar al-Fikr Beirut, 1996) Kitabal-Shahadat, 4:388.

Al-Haskafi, Muhammad Alauddin, Al-Dar al-Mukhtar, (Dar al-Fikr Beirut, 1996) Kitabal-Shahadat, 4:388.

۔ Al-Ghazali, Abu Hamid Muhammad bin Muhammad Al-Ghazali Al-Tusi, al-Mustafi,Tahqiq Muhammad Abdul Salam Abd al-Shafi, (Dar al-Kitab al-Ulamiya, al-Tabbat al-Awli, 1403 AH, 1993), 57:1

۔ Sarkhsi, Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Abi Sahl Shams al-Aymah al-Sarkhsi, Usul al-Sarkhsi, (Dar al-Marafah Beirut, 1996), 120:2

۔ Al:Baqara:2:29

۔ Al-Jathiyah:45:13

۔ Al:Aaraf: 7:32

۔ Al-Anaam:6:145

۔ Al.Nahl:17:116

۔ Al-Qurtubi, Imam Muhammad bin Ahmad bin Abu Bakr bin Farah Abu Abdullah Ansari, Al-Jaami-Le-Ahkam al-Qur’an, (Dar al-Fikr, Beirut, 1998), 19

۔ Al-Anaam:6:119

۔ Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail, Al-Jami’ al-Sahih, (Maktab-e-Haqqania, 1415 AH), al-Riqam: 38

Al-Baqara: 2:29

۔ Imam Muslim, Abul Hussain Muslim bin al-Hajjaj bin Muslim al-Qashiri, Sahih Muslim, (Dar al-Jail Beirut, 1998) Number: 6265

۔ Ibn Majah, Muhammad Ibn Yazid Ibn Abdullah Ibn Majah Al-Qazwini al-Rabi, Sunan Ibn Majah, (Darlfiqr Beirut, 1986) Number: 3367

۔ Imam Zarkashi, Badr al-Din Muhammad bin Bahadur bin Abdullah al-Zarkashi, Al-Bahr al-Muhayt, 1998, (Dar al-Kitab al-Ilamiya, 2000), Al-Asal fi al-Munafi wa fi al-Muzdar al-Manaa, 324:4

۔ Imam al-Hakim, Muhammad bin Abdullah Abu Abdullah al-Hakim al-Nishapuri, al- Mustadrik for al-Hakim, research by Mustafa Abdul Qadir Atta, Taleeqat on Al-Dhahbi fi al-Takhlis (Dar al-Kitab al-Ulamiya Beirut, 1411), Kitab al-Tafseer, Tafseer Surat Maryam, Number: 3:145،419

۔ Ibn Abd al-Barr, Abu Umar Yusuf bin Abdullah bin Muhammad bin Abd Al-Nimri al-Qurtubi, (publisher of Al-Qurtuba Foundation 1412), 95:3

۔ Adh-Dhariyat:51:21

۔ Mansoor Muhammad Mansoor Hafnawi, Suspicions and Effects in Criminal Punishment in Islamic Jurisprudence Compared to Law, (Muttabat al-Amanat, 1986) (259)

۔ Imam Jarjani, Ali bin Muhammad bin Ali, Al-Tarifat al-Jarjani, Dar al-Fikr, Beirut, 1999) 152

۔ Ibn Qayyim Joziya, Muhammad Ibn Abu Bakr Damaschi, al-Tarq al-Hikmiyyah fi al-Siyasat al-Sharia, (Dar al-Fikr 1989), 99.

۔ Yusuf:12:18

۔ Yusuf:12:26,28

۔ Al-Jami Le-Ahkam al-Qur'an:9:149,179

۔ Altaf Hussain, Altaf Hussain Langriyal, Jihat al-Islam January-June 2015, 8/189

۔ Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-Talaq, Number: 4999,

۔ Imam Nasa'i, Ahmad bin Shoaib Nasa'i, Sunan Nasa'i, Kitab al-Talaq, (Maktab-e-Rehmania, Urdu Bazar Lahore) Number: 3480

۔ Imam Qarafi, Abu al-Abbas Shahab al-Din Ahmad ibn Idris ibn Abd al-Rahman al-Maliki al-Shahir al-Qarafi, Al-Farooq, (Alam al-Kitab Beirut 1422), 146:4. See also: Taqi al-Din, Taj al-Din Abd al-Wahhab ibn Taqi al-Din al-Sabki, al-Ashbah wa al-Natayr, ( Dar al-Kitab al-Ulamiya, al-Tabbat al-Awli 1411 AH), 49:1

۔ Dr. Fouad Abd al-Munaim Ahmad, Al-Basmata al-Waraatiyah and Durha in Criminal Evidence between the Shari’ah and the Law, Al-Muktab Al-Masriya, 14

۔ Rajesh Bardale, Principles of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, JP

Medical College and Hospital Ltd. New Delhi, India, Edition1, 2011,p 7-9

۔ Edited by U S Congress , Congressional Record, V. 149, PT. 1, January 7, 2003

۔ Jahat al-Islam, January-June 2015, 8, p. 192

۔ Majlat al-Ahkam al-Adliyyah, Al-Maqala al-Thaniyyah fi Bayan al-Qa’maal al-Kiliya al-Fiqhiyyah, Noor Muhammad Karkhana Trading Books, Aram Bagh, Karachi,

۔ Baltimore man released from prison after 18 years when DNA evidence proves his innocence in 1998 killing.see also:http://www.foxnews.com/us/2016/10/06/man-freed-after-18-years-in-prison-wants-innocence-declared.html.

۔ Jahat al-Islam, January-June 2015, 8, p. 201

۔ Al-Zahili, Allama Wahbat Al-Zahili, Qadaya al-Fiqh and Al-Fikr al-Mudaqim, (Damascus Dar al-Fikr, Al-Zahili Maktaba al-Asad, 2006), 429:8

۔ Ibn al-Athir, al-Mubarak bin Muhammad al-Shaibani al-Jazari, Jami al-Asul-fi-Ahadith-e-Rasool, (Muktab Al-Hilwani 1969), 286:12.

۔ انعقدت الحلقة النقاشية على مدار يومي الأربعاء والخميس 28 ، 29 /1/1421 هـ الموافق 3 ، 4 /5/2000 م بفندق الميريديان ــ قاعة الصالحية ــ الكويت، .وقد بلغ عدد ساعات العمل في الحلقة 45 , 10 ساعة في ست جلسات ( أربع جلسات يوم الأربعاء . جلستان صباحاً ومساءً.وجلستان يوم الخميس . واحدة صباحاً والأخرى مساء، خصصت الجلسات الأربع الأولى يوم الأربعاء على مدار سبع ساعات لإلقاء ملخص بحث الدكتور سعد هلالي عن البصمة الوراثية وعلائقها الشرعية واعتباره ورقة عمل أساسية ، أعقبها المناقشات التفصيلية

۔ Jihat-ul-Islam,January to June, volume 8,2015,page no;207

۔ Wahran Al-Jamhuriya Al-Jaziriyya al-Shaabiyyah, 26 Shawwal – 2 Dhu al-Qaida 1433 AH, corresponding to: 13 – 18 September (September) 2012 Decisions No. 186 – 194

۔ Imam al-Shami, Muhammad Amin Ibn Abidin al-Shami, Hashiya Rid al-Muhthar Ali al-Dur al-Mukhtar, Kitab al-Nikah, Mutalib al-Tuzaj Barsal Kitab, (Maktab-e-fikr Beirut, 1420) 12:3

۔ Islamic Fiqh Academy, New Issues and Decisions of Fiqh Academy (EFA Publications, New Delhi India, 2012), 413

۔ Islamic Ideological Council Government of Pakistan Islamabad, Annual Report, 2012, 1433, 98

Muhaddith, Muhammad Shafi Madani, Reasons for Harmat Image and Tabligh-Deen in Modern Times, Lahore, Majlis al-Tahqiq al-Islami, June 2008.

۔ www.bbc.com/urdu/pakistan/story/۲۰۰۵/۰۵/۰۵۰۵۲۱۲

۔ EFA Publications, Shariah Arguments on DNA Test and Genetic Science, (EFA Publications New Delhi, 2013), 172

۔ Al-Raqq al-Hikmiyyah fi al-Siyasat al-Sharia, 4

۔Code of Judiciary ۔1898، section 510۔ The Law of Martyrdom ،1984,Article112,84,79,78,74,73,61,60,59,49,48

Electronics Transactions Ordinance 2002 Section 38, 37

Federal Shariat Court 2013, PLD 72015 ,PLD 7B LAHORE

,SCMR.274

Published
2022-12-31
How to Cite
Mufti Dilawar Khan, Dr Hafiz Muhammad Haussain. (2022). Effective enforcement of Sharia and Pakistani law through embedding DNA in the evidence Act An Analytical Review. Al Qalam, 27(2), 28-54. https://doi.org/10.51506/al qalam.v27i2.1790